Comment: Hiya. I've ummed and ahhed about this but decided in the end I'd be honest with you. I've rated a 5 because you met swap requirements etc, but did feel that your ATC was quite poor. The last thing I want to do is offend you or dishearten you, I promise that's not my intention.
I read your letter in the envelope first and when I read you'd chosen Kate I thought it was a really interesting choice, but when I got the ATC out I was disappointed as I felt you could have done so much more than paint an ATC red and paint the word 'Kate' on it. I felt like there was no 'A' in your 'ATC', if you see what I mean!
Your other ratings are good, so perhaps it was an off day? Again, I just want to say that I don't mean to offend you or leave you feeling disheartened, but maybe next time add a bit more to it?
xxx
Comment: Thanks for the lovely ATCs! I especially like the one with woven paper.
It would be helpful if next time you wrote the swap name on the ATCs or included a note with that info on it. Thanks again!
Comment: Thanks for the very nice ATC Karen, I love to make and receive hand drawn/painted cards so I was happy to get yours. I hope you're enjoying Swap-bot so far.